logoalt Hacker News

lubujacksonyesterday at 11:56 PM1 replyview on HN

The article poses if AI will be a tool, a collaborator or an oracle. Why not all 3?

If mathematics is human understanding of logical consequences, understanding is the priority. But if AI proves something we can't understand but can utilize, that is a different sort of useful.

We are getting awfully close to "the answer of the universe is 42" and having it not be a joke...


Replies

fn-motetoday at 12:46 AM

I don’t know about “close”, but there are certainly results in math that are considered deep because they require the use of a “Hard Theorem” at some point. That kind of building on top of something Very Difficult is still possible without understanding the “Very Difficult” part. I’d say a lot of not-amazing math is built by believing the platform works but not being able to built it yourself.

I couldn’t build an internal combustion engine or even a plastic box, so maybe there’s nothing wrong with this approach.