logoalt Hacker News

ndsipa_pomulast Saturday at 9:35 PM3 repliesview on HN

I'm not saying that people shouldn't want to integrate, I'm saying that "demanding" it is problematic. Imagine grandparents being brought over from a different country and they don't speak the language - should they be forced to attend language school? What level of language ability would be considered the minimum and does that also include reading/writing?

By all means provide encouragement and resources so that people can adapt to their new situation, but don't demand it.


Replies

int_19htoday at 9:35 PM

I think that most people arguing for integration are fine with grandparents being left to their devices. Where they get antsy is when the next generation grows up self-segregated into their own distinct culture.

dijittoday at 7:58 PM

My Polish great-granddad didn’t have a home to return to following WWII and the Iron Curtain- they forced him to learn the language.

Because not everyone in the UK could even hope to bend to work with Polish as a language in 1946.

port11yesterday at 5:52 AM

Yeah, I know. That’s why I say that no one is ever happy with where you set the limit. I think demanding A2 in language is reasonable, for example. Yes, demanding, even if it’s in a reasonably long timespan. We demand much more out of everyone born in the country, don’t we?

show 1 reply