logoalt Hacker News

dueyfinstertoday at 11:33 AM1 replyview on HN

I'd be curious if any prosecutions are a real deterrent - it seems not. YouTube has to follow the DMCA but also enforces its stricter content ID, with popular creators getting hit (and being vocal) and YouTube seeming to "fix" the issues (until next time).

Ultimately the whole system needs reform now where it's easier than ever via LLMs to send off these notices.


Replies

TeMPOraLtoday at 12:16 PM

AFAIU, the whole deal is that the bogus claims never actually reach the DMCA stage - big platforms implement their moderation policies and copyright claim handling specifically to avoid involving the legal system. It's that intermediate layer that incentivizes automated, bogus claims, as there's effectively zero consequences to them.