logoalt Hacker News

Working with AI

31 pointsby comma_attoday at 2:53 PM8 commentsview on HN

Comments

thorumtoday at 3:36 PM

Interesting read! Creating tests is highlighted as something Claude did well, but it strikes me that all the weaker rejected solutions could have been avoided if it were really good at designing intelligent tests for itself. For example, the first solution “was very specific to the reported bug and wouldn’t have fixed the general case” and the third suggestion “prevented the perfectly valid use of as conversion expressions in go commands as well”. I imagine both of these cases could have been noticed and avoided by the agent if it had planned out adequate tests ahead of time.

recursivedoubtstoday at 3:14 PM

hello all, this is an article I wrote up on my interaction with an agent, Claude, in fixing a bug in the hyperscript parser

it was a rather mundane bug, but i thought the interaction was interesting and worth analyzing to show where AI is very strong and where it is not as strong

waffletowertoday at 3:51 PM

I disagree with the trope -- (AI effects) "the slow dulling of our intellects". I am old enough to remember my career change, being a developer in the Apple ecosystem, confident with Objective-C and native system libraries in iOS and MacOS. I changed direction using a very different software stack in cloud services as a data engineer with deep utilization of Clojure. I have personal projects that I occasionally would return to in the former world -- often a decade or more later. I saw what I forgot immediately; but soon after, with engagement, I saw how quickly I was able to remember. Extended use of AI for me has exactly this footprint. Even "use it or lose it" is wrong -- "use it when you need to" is honestly more like it -- the brain is plastic. Some AI fears are warranted, this isn't one of them.

nsonhatoday at 5:08 PM

AI makes the case for htmx, we don't have to think about the spaghetti code, AI does it for us /s

varun_chtoday at 3:27 PM

maybe slightly unrelated but the new htmx homepage (https://four.htmx.org/) feels a little ironic, seemingly written with tailwindcss and a full JS ecosystem Astro build system. It also has the ‘vibey’ ‘hypey’ landing page design that’s hard to describe but you’ll find on any web framework, rather than dropping you to docs like the old site.

Compared to the original simple HTML site it’s really surprising to see from the grugbrain.dev author!

show 1 reply