logoalt Hacker News

microgptlast Monday at 8:07 PM6 repliesview on HN

Who supports "open borders" and what do they support exactly?


Replies

loeglast Monday at 8:48 PM

A lot of but certainly not all Dems (for example, Jayapal) support essentially unlimited asylum claims admitted to the US while claims are processed (i.e., not "Remain in Mexico"). This is a de facto open border policy; the vast majority of claims are bogus, but the claim gets you into the country and then most who are denied will overstay illegally as well.

show 1 reply
criddelllast Monday at 9:16 PM

Radiolab (the podcast) did a good series on border policy that was pretty informative.

IIRC, the US-Mexico border was never open, but it was quite porous. People would come to the US, work for a season to make some money, then go home.

Then once border security started to be tightened, leaving was too risky so people would stay leading to a huge increase in the number of undocumented people living in the US.

jimbokunlast Monday at 10:56 PM

It’s shorthand for the policies of the Biden administration, who oversaw an unprecedented level of immigration.

felixgallolast Monday at 9:08 PM

nobody does. It's a made up fantasy by fox news.

nailerlast Monday at 9:09 PM

Here in NY:

- Brad Lander (NY-10, defeated incumbent Dan Goldman): Longtime advocate for abolishing ICE. He has been arrested while intervening at immigration courts to protect immigrants and ensure due process. "I first called for abolishing ICE in 2018... Our movement is fighting to abolish ICE." (Social media/campaign statements). Vowed to fight ICE's "cruelty" and protect "immigrant neighbors." He emphasizes sanctuary city enforcement and due process for all.

- Darializa Avila Chevalier (NY-13, defeated incumbent Adriano Espaillat): DSA member, strong abolitionist stance. Supports abolishing ICE, opposes all forms of deportation and detention. "I have yet to come up with a reason for why deportation has been used in a way that isn't rooted in deeply racist ideology." (June 2026 interview). Called free movement an "ideal vision" (noting capital moves freely but people are restricted). She also opposes policing and borders in broader terms.

- Claire Valdez (NY-7): DSA-backed progressive who won her primary. Part of the Mamdani slate emphasizing immigrant justice; aligned with the group's platform calling to demilitarize borders, end detention/deportations, and expand rights/services for all immigrants regardless of status

show 1 reply
xdennislast Monday at 8:39 PM

Biden. His policies led to a huge increase in illegal immigration.

Look at the huge jump due to his policies: https://www.economist.com/content-assets/images/20240127_EPC...

The same was not true for Obama, who was actually much better than Bush.

show 5 replies