logoalt Hacker News

willmarchlast Monday at 9:22 PM2 repliesview on HN

What state policies are you referring to? Laws/rights should apply equally to all people or else they are not really rights (are they?).

No, Enlightenment principles come from the idea that rights and laws belong to all people (citizen or otherwise) and the founders believed that to be "self-evident" and "unalienable" to all humans. The US Supreme Court has ruled as such again and again (non-citizens have protections of the US Constitution), and Enlightenment thinkers (and any decent person) would agree.

Your entire argument (and everything after) can be ignored because your premise is not just flawed, it is entirely incorrect (false) and goes against any principle of human rights that I'm aware of.


Replies

mjburgesslast Monday at 9:24 PM

States are not the creations of the enlightment

I'll await your grant of medicare to the population of africa

show 1 reply
jimbokunlast Monday at 10:36 PM

Recent Supreme Court decisions are nowhere near your position. They have given the President a lot of leeway to deport non-citizens. If everyone geographically in the country had equal standing, this would not be possible.

show 1 reply