logoalt Hacker News

rayinerlast Tuesday at 2:44 PM2 repliesview on HN

I’m not saying it’s literally a tree. My point is that we need vastly more power to upgrade to the next level of civilization.


Replies

tech_kenlast Tuesday at 2:52 PM

Right but “upgrading to the next level” is exactly the type of cognitive error that I’m against, it’s forward-looking Whig history. There is no “levels” of civilization, there’s only the arrangements we have now and the ones that will occur in the future. Maybe those arrangements will have different pros and cons than we have now, maybe they’ll have more sophisticated engineering practices, but there’s no objective “development score” that is being maximized it’s just more humanity.

show 1 reply
pfdietzlast Tuesday at 4:03 PM

How do you know nuclear is even on the "tech tree", rather than being a blind alley? Isn't this argument just assuming what you're trying to show?