logoalt Hacker News

rayineryesterday at 6:06 PM3 repliesview on HN

Jurisdiction is not some singular concept that means the same thing in every context. You can have jurisdiction over some things in some contexts and not have jurisdiction over other things in other contexts.


Replies

sanderjdyesterday at 8:41 PM

Surely "subject to the jurisdiction" must mean subject to any jurisdiction, or it is completely meaningless.

show 1 reply
rootusrootusyesterday at 6:19 PM

In that case, the use of the word jurisdiction in the 14th Amendment is meaningless, too ambiguous to rely on. Unless we think the Constitution should be living, breathing, and adapt to the current political environment. Is that the current conservative viewpoint?

show 2 replies