logoalt Hacker News

ndriscolllast Tuesday at 7:00 PM1 replyview on HN

The EC doesn't "break" equal weights. The US is not a direct democracy; it's a federation of states. The states (semi-sovereign entities) get votes, not people. This is an explicit, intentional design decision.

If anything, we probably need to better subdivide states, and in several cases, at this point large metros (e.g. LA or NYC) should probably become city-states with direct representation in Congress but a loss of governing power and senatorial representation from the rest of their (present) state. e.g. there's basically no reason for voters in LA to have any influence over the governance of Redding.


Replies

rho138last Tuesday at 11:30 PM

Even more taxation without representation, nice.

show 1 reply