logoalt Hacker News

Bendertoday at 3:44 PM1 replyview on HN

That does not make what I said not relevant. People are spread out across the country and kids in rural areas are just as valuable as kids in cities. I would never trust anyone that says otherwise. Also most of the land is not walkable in any realistic sense. Busses and cars are not likely going away for the duration of this short civilization. We will hit the great filter long before better options may have arrived.


Replies

vel0citytoday at 4:05 PM

It makes the phrase "most places are not a city" extremely misleading in terms of talking about school busses. The extreme majority of school busses and kids going to school do so in urban areas, i.e. in cities. Like, sure, over 40% of the US has zero inhabitants, so yeah "most of the US isn't cities". But its not like there are a lot of school busses and elementary schools in places where zero people live.

> kids in rural areas are just as valuable as kids in cities

I never said otherwise. I'm just pointing out its misleading to act like most of the US population live in rural areas.

> Busses and cars are not likely going away for the duration of this short civilization

The majority of this short civilization existed without busses and cars being a requirement. Seems strange it can't possibly exist without them now, or at least a significantly reduced societal need on them to have a basic functional existence for a decent chunk of the society.

show 2 replies