logoalt Hacker News

semiquaveryesterday at 10:52 PM4 repliesview on HN

Do you not say your words one-at-a-time like everyone else? Otherwise I can’t see how my comment is “wrong”


Replies

tuvixyesterday at 11:18 PM

Even if you could understand human cognition to the level required to say, confidently, that it’s done one word at a time, it’s likely not! Natural language is not a prerequisite for human intelligence, as evidenced by the fact that we went from primates to commenting on HN.

Natural language is, however, a prerequisite for the existence of LLMs. It’s more similar to methods for storing and retrieving information, like the printing press or a database, than it is to a sentient being.

That’s not to say that LLMs can’t do crazy things, because they already have. Our language can encode a whole lot of information, and it’s incredible that we’ve found a way to distill that so effectively.

show 2 replies
artisinyesterday at 11:22 PM

Only one word at a time!?! It's time you embrace the way of the diffusion model and hazily refine your entire thought until it's coherent.

root_axistoday at 2:57 AM

> Do you not say your words one-at-a-time like everyone else

You're conflating being autoregressive with being sequential.