logoalt Hacker News

echelontoday at 1:39 AM10 repliesview on HN

Sounds like the Apple monopoly has made yet another industry its bitch.

These companies are giving up sovereignty of their primary product to a company that can steer away customer loyalty and disrupt any hope these companies have of increasing their already scant margins.

Any car should be able to interface with a phone without Apple or Google's legally binding terms and NDAs. The direction of control should be on the side of the customer first, and the automotive company second.

Where the hell are the regulators? This is not okay.


Replies

stephen_gtoday at 3:29 AM

That doesn’t make any sense… The comment you’re replying to is about people’s desire for a particular feature, but pretty much any car that supports CarPlay also supports the Android equivalent, as well as still having media playback and often some kind of navigation without either!

Your comment would only make sense in a hypothetical situation where the car infotainment only worked if you had an iPhone or if there was some kind of exclusivity agreements to preclude it working with Android, but that isn’t the case in any circumstance I’m aware of.

majormajortoday at 1:51 AM

Seems like, if anything, the right action for regulators would be to enforce car manufacturers to not refuse to support existing consumer connectivity protocols... or at least not unless they can come up with something at least as good. And definitely something that isn't "pay us a data subscription so we can track you too while you use a crappier re-implementation of what your phone can already do."

Or "we're gonna cut off our older models to force people towards new cars instead of older ones." That's a bad pattern to let people selling $30,000+ devices get access to.

show 2 replies
dgacmutoday at 1:41 AM

Consumers having a preference is not ok?

I feel the same way about Android auto. I refuse to be locked into some terrible, never updated or expensive subscription vendor nav unit. I have a phone. I want to be able to use it.

show 1 reply
asveikautoday at 4:00 AM

Android Auto is also a thing.

aetchtoday at 4:03 AM

Do you understand how headunits work and have you ever sat in a car? It doesn’t sound like it since you think cars are forced to use CarPlay.

pertymcperttoday at 1:41 AM

What do you want the regulators to do to Apple in this case? What have they done wrong?

Jtsummerstoday at 1:46 AM

> Where the hell are the regulators? This is not okay.

To quote a wise man:

>> We need to stop this helicopter civilization bullshit.

>>We're building 1984 to protect from god knows what imaginary harms.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48755473

show 1 reply
rufiustoday at 1:42 AM

Android Auto is in the vast majority of cars that also have CarPlay.

What’s your point?

Rekindle8090today at 3:41 AM

[dead]

tryagainiantoday at 4:05 AM

Ah yes, the solution to any and every problem, real or imagined, is more government.