logoalt Hacker News

542458today at 12:00 PM4 repliesview on HN

I'm not a deep-in-the-weeds expert, but if I had to put together an "obvious long rifle mistakes in fiction" article, it’d probably be:

* People pumping shotguns after every round, or unnecessarily cycling the bolt after every round

* Wrong action type for the gun

* Wrong shotgun ammo for the context

* Wrong safety type for the gun (most long guns have safeties, but they are operated in a variety of ways)

* Magazine vs clip vs chamber vs tube

* Shotgun impacts launching people across rooms, or unrealistic recoil (both too high and too low) for the weapon type


Replies

RayeEvtuchtoday at 12:16 PM

Many long guns are not semi-auto and have to have their action cycled after each round. that's super common.

waltwalthertoday at 12:46 PM

Generally, all long guns that are not auto/semi-auto must be cycled after every shot in order to chamber another round. This includes pump-action, bolt-action, and lever-action rifles/shotguns. There are exceptions, such as revolver rifles.

There are also instances when semi-auto pistols might need to be cycled after every round.

defrosttoday at 12:03 PM

How about accounting for Coriolis "force" in addition to drop and wind when shooting ULR 5,000 yards?

Have you seen that in a film? Is it actually a thing, can you ignore it?

show 1 reply
calyth2018today at 3:46 PM

Buckshot spread is another common mistake in fiction, e.g. when it's close you still need to aim