logoalt Hacker News

andersonpicotoday at 12:49 PM2 repliesview on HN

But distribution isn't the only crime here, obtaining the material illegally apparently is a crime too. And the damn robot can also spit me harry Potter verbatim so I don't know how it would also not be distribution?


Replies

mapontoseventhstoday at 1:16 PM

If I read Harry Potter I will remember some parts verbatim. Others I will tecall in only an abridged and lossy way.

Does that make my brain copyright infringement? Does Disney now own all my output forever because some small part of me now has Harry Potter embedded?

show 6 replies
vlian2088today at 1:00 PM

>And the damn robot can also spit me harry Potter verbatim so I don't know how it would also not be distribution?

if you prompt it to, yes. just like your browser dutifully navigates to any copyright-infringing resource and GETs and POSTs whatever you ask of it.

(also it can't, not really, only small snippets before going off rails. LLMs aren't magic, they can't losslessly compress an exabyte of training data into a few terabytes of weights.)