logoalt Hacker News

hn_throwaway_99yesterday at 8:22 PM3 repliesview on HN

Just a general thought on your comment style. Summarily declaring something "evil" means that you're not really interested in hearing any other comments on the topic, and that additional data or analysis of the issue will have no effect on your opinion.

Which, in and of itself, may be fine for you, but I find it to be the absolute least useful comments on HN.


Replies

qlmyesterday at 8:26 PM

I appreciate when somebody speaks with conviction about their beliefs.

show 1 reply
mschuster91yesterday at 8:32 PM

> Summarily declaring something "evil" means that you're not really interested in hearing any other comments on the topic, and that additional data or analysis of the issue will have no effect on your opinion.

I'd say it is in the end an ethics issue. Sure, the tone may be offputting, but... I think there is value in having people around who actually hold beliefs and aren't as quickly willing to put their beliefs aside. Society as a whole benefits from a corrective to ultra-progressives - even if what the progressives want is a good thing (which, to be clear, it almost always is!), move too fast and you end up losing the masses along the way.

show 1 reply
solenoid0937yesterday at 8:26 PM

[dead]