logoalt Hacker News

Cider9986yesterday at 4:24 PM6 repliesview on HN

>With 395,608 regulatory restrictions, California is the most heavily regulated state in the nation, according to the report. On average, states have 135,000 regulatory restrictions in administrative rules, with California's regulations more than doubling the national average.

https://www.usnews.com/news/best-states/articles/2020-11-03/...

I wonder how many they've added in 5 years. Do all these laws improve peoples lives?


Replies

m4ck_yesterday at 4:46 PM

Well despite all that regulation, they're an economic powerhouse, they must be doing something right. CA is far from perfect but at least they occasionally aspire to do something for the benefit of their citizens - not something I can say for my 'least regulated' state that mostly just saps money from the federal government.

show 5 replies
tikhonjyesterday at 4:27 PM

Regulations aren't fungible, so this is not a particularly meaningful perspective.

matwoodyesterday at 5:04 PM

Because of the power CA has, many of the regulations they pass around health and safety end up benefiting other states because it's cheaper to simply implement it nationwide.

rcontiyesterday at 5:24 PM

Is there a reason to think these should or should not scale with size of population?

vrganjyesterday at 4:31 PM

All of them? No. Some of them? Yes.

Some examples:

* ARL / Automatic Renewal Law: If a company allows you to sign up for a subscription online, they also must provide an immediate, straightforward way to cancel it online.

* SB 478: No bullshit junk fees tacked on to prices. Any price displayed, be it for concerts, hotels, or whatever else, must be the full, out-the-door price.

* SB 244: Right to Repair: Electronics and appliance manufacturers must make diagnostic tools, manuals etc available for at least 7 years after manufacture.

show 2 replies
mc32yesterday at 4:28 PM

I hope they refactor and harmonize them at some point to reduce duplication, contradiction as well as proliferation.