logoalt Hacker News

ben_wyesterday at 7:32 PM1 replyview on HN

Currently writing a draft blog post on all the issues (and non-issues) with these things, it is now long enough (7k words) I'm slightly wondering if it's less "a blog post" and more "one section of a decent sized book on why we can't have nice things".

Here's a visual to consider the implications of things you can do with actually one million satellites of the kind of size scale being discussed:

https://raw.githubusercontent.com/BenWheatley/blog/refs/head...


Replies

JumpCrisscrossyesterday at 7:35 PM

> Yes, they really would be this closely spaced: Earth's circumference is 40 million meters

Satellites don’t orbit on the ground, which makes the 40m spacing nonsense. And nobody proposes putting a million 120 kW satellites in a single orbit.

They really would never be that closely spaced. To approach those densities in a single orbital shell you’d need hundreds of billions of birds in orbit. Spread across all of LEO (and only LEO) we’re talking orders of magnitudes more satellites (like, quadrillions).

show 2 replies