logoalt Hacker News

Egg consumption inversely correlated with Alzheimer's

58 pointsby natbennetttoday at 12:48 AM36 commentsview on HN

Comments

pinkmuffineretoday at 2:51 AM

I’m copying this comment from discussion two months ago

> Caveat:

> > Funding [...] The analyses in this study were supported by an investigator-initiated grant from the American Egg Board. [...]

show 2 replies
ChiMantoday at 2:59 AM

Quality of this study aside, and n of 1 here, my own state of mind, clarity of thought, and sleep are all noticeably better when I'm eating 2 or 3 eggs a day, 3 to 5 days a week. (I might go 7 days, but an independent value placed on dietary variety prevents that--perhaps foolishly when I notice what I'm eating on off days instead of the eggs.)

Regardless, this whole eggs-are-evil thing has probably done more to harm the health of Westerners than any other dietary advice, with the possible exception of the fat-is-evil nonsense.

show 2 replies
willis936today at 2:50 AM

Why would having alzheimer's reduce people's desire to eat eggs?

show 1 reply
adjejmxbdjdntoday at 2:03 AM

> In addition, to evaluate potential bias because of unmeasured systematic differences between consumers and nonconsumers, we conducted a sensitivity analysis excluding vegans. Vegans comprised a substantial portion of the zero egg consumption group, which could disproportionately influence this group, and they often differ in other lifestyle or health-related characteristics.

So they eliminated vegans from the sensitivity analysis despite them comprising a substantial portion of the no-egg group.

If the analysis doesn’t hold with vegans included, it’s probably saying a lot about dairy rather than eggs.

ChrisArchitecttoday at 2:38 AM

Some previous discussion 2 months ago:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48038873

aussieguy1234today at 1:11 AM

Since the study was done on Seventh Day Adventists, it's worth noting that they are all vegetarian, so no meat based protein options here...

show 4 replies
bastard_optoday at 2:31 AM

I tried to look, but the google captcha wouldn't let me, finally gave up trying.

tfwnopmttoday at 1:48 AM

Cancer is also inversely correlated with alzheimer's.

Phrased another way, egg consumption is correlated with cancer.

show 1 reply