logoalt Hacker News

bruce511today at 8:50 AM2 repliesview on HN

The reason I think it is hard in the US is because there is a very strong "work or die" ethic in the US. Everything is driven by money. Even basic things like healthcare are driven by money. Your life after retirement is determined by how much money you accumulated. The word-association between "poor" and "lazy" is strong. Taxation should be light. Each man should keep what he accumulates.

BI by contrast values people over money. It recognises not just the social responsibility of the rich to the poor, but also the dignity of being human.

Some countries are further along that path than others. Health care, education, unemployment benefits, are all steps towards BI. The wealthy are taxed to pay for the poor. Ultimately the suppresses the excess, while raising the floor.

From a cultural point of view, the US has many steps to take before society is really for (real) BI.


Replies

ChrisMarshallNYtoday at 9:39 AM

I have an Irish friend that got a Ph.D, while on the dole.

That would never happen, in the US. We have a strong “Why do they get special treatment?” thing going on.

show 1 reply
mlrtimetoday at 12:09 PM

Top 10% already pays 70.5% of all federal income taxes. US high income payers are already taxed to pay the poor.

Almost half of US federal tax payers pay 0 income tax.

show 1 reply