logoalt Hacker News

BoingBoomTschaktoday at 11:58 AM2 repliesview on HN

Moby Dick had a much worse ratio of "size of good novel trying to get out / actual size", in my opinion.


Replies

arjietoday at 2:20 PM

Huh, that’s surprising to me. The beginning details about the whales and whatnot surprised me but once I got going it was just marvelous. I’m not a very good book critic but it just had such a sensation of the sea and being crew on a ship run by an obsessive (that in itself somewhat interesting in that the narrator is just side character to the protagonist). And I loved the characterization of his obsession as a “cruel emperor” and the way men love water (“set a man to walking and he will infallibly lead you to water”).

It’s been a long time since I read the book but it was doubtless one of the most enjoyable I’ve read.

velcrovantoday at 1:26 PM

Moby Dick has a bad (high) ratio of “people who try to read it like a thriller novel” to “people who read it for what it is”.

show 1 reply