logoalt Hacker News

truenotoday at 7:42 PM4 repliesview on HN

do these damn projects even push the proposed edits up back to openstreetmap?

insanely shameful if not


Replies

shrinks99today at 9:19 PM

Yes, CoMaps lets users submit basic data that updates OSM for addresses and POIs. It's a harder problem than you may initially think too, quite often the delivery format of OSM data differs in schema from the DB format. In the case of OrganicMaps and CoMaps, they both generate offline-optimized map formats for distribution.

superjantoday at 8:10 PM

They can’t do so automatically. Osm Editors must approve. Apparantly OSM fears legislation when people copy info from google maps. They like to see evidence, like street sign photos. In my limited experience anyway.

show 1 reply
gpvostoday at 8:01 PM

I assume they all do, it's nigh impossible to maintain your own data fork and keep reconciling your users' edits and the updates from OSM.

hk__2today at 8:10 PM

Of course they do.