logoalt Hacker News

bijowo1676today at 4:05 PM4 repliesview on HN

Voice interface is the future, just have voice assistant do everything without relying on knobs nor touch screen

same way people just talk to claude code via whisper


Replies

drakythetoday at 4:13 PM

Lordy I hope not. Cannot imagine having to childproof my car's entertainment system, or make sure I don't sing a trigger word, or try to turn on the defroster to dehumidify the windshield during an intense rain storm where I can barely hear myself think.

Also: I don't want a microphone in my car at all times. Thank you.

show 1 reply
nancyminusonetoday at 4:22 PM

Hell no. I'd sooner tear out my own vocal cords than accept this future.

macintuxtoday at 4:13 PM

No. No, please, no. I won't buy a car that relies on voice for anything, and I really don't want to rent one either. Wildly inefficient, slow, unpredictable.

AnatolySkubatoday at 5:16 PM

Voice makes sense as a third input mode, but it seems like a poor replacement for the controls you need while stressed or time-constrained. In a car the real UX test isn't "can the system eventually understand me?", it's "can I do this eyes-free, in noise, with high confidence, in under a second?" That's why defrost, wipers, volume, and temperature feel fundamentally different from "navigate to X". Touch is fine for discoverability, voice is fine for occasional commands, but safety-critical/high-frequency actions still want dedicated hardware.