logoalt Hacker News

Certhastoday at 1:22 PM2 repliesview on HN

Infrastructure should not be (purely) profit driven. To improve profits for train operators, the simple option is to cut lines serving small and rural communities. The economics are much worse than serving large cities. Same for cell coverage and broadband internet. Most profitable is to just not cover a few percent of the population.

There is a point where technology becomes foundational for participating in society. And then it needs to be regulated to be available to everyone.


Replies

groundzeros2015today at 1:33 PM

> the simple option is to cut lines serving small and rural communities

We don’t see this in practice to though. Three examples:

1. In the airline industry big airlines don’t go everywhere for this reasons but small local airlines fill the gap due to market opportunity.

2. Changes in technology enable big companies to operate more efficiently. See starlink.

3. Big companies know that ubiquity is important for their brand. In practice Amazon will deliver packages across the US.

show 4 replies
account42today at 2:43 PM

Yes, we need to update what is considered essential infrastructure in the digital age.