logoalt Hacker News

73738384today at 3:47 PM4 repliesview on HN

The European Comission is the top decision maker of the EU. The European citizen has zero (0) influence on the members or actions of the EC. No different than the politburo in China.


Replies

chrystalkeytoday at 7:41 PM

That is incorrect. Usually, the legislation happens in the trilogue, which is an abomination and everything but well representing it's citizens interest, but the Commission can do very very little if the council says no. That again is a body consisting of elected officials with varying degrees of distance from a direct election. Best example for a change: everything that happened after Magyar replaced Orban in the council. This is just to say... Its complicated. The EU can definitely do with a reform and better, stronger democratic legitimacy.

iamnotheretoday at 3:49 PM

It is slightly different than China, China has implemented hotlines/apps for citizen complaints in response to social pressure, and it actually attempts to address those complaints.

show 3 replies
onraglanroadtoday at 4:01 PM

Apart from the fact it can't make decisions.

It can only propose; the decision is made by the EU parliament.

show 1 reply
raverbashingtoday at 4:01 PM

> The European citizen has zero (0) influence on the members or actions of the EC

Whenever one reads EC you need to read: "All of the heads of state in a trenchcoat". Macron, Merz, etc

And yet this is an EP maneuver

And let's not forget on the American lobbyists pushing for it (Including Big Tech)

show 1 reply