logoalt Hacker News

carlosjobimtoday at 4:39 PM2 repliesview on HN

The effective difference is of course that they could easily get that book from somewhere else if they want it.

If I'm prevented from bringing my dog into a restaurant, that doesn't mean that dogs are banned. It means I have to go to the restaurant on the other side of the street.

If McDonald's doesn't serve any hard liquor it doesn't mean that alcohol has been banned in the country.


Replies

mossTechniciantoday at 5:48 PM

Is it really that cut and dry? A technically competent person might easily access a book while living in an authoritarian country, while someone who grows up in an authoritarian family in a "free" country might be prevented from reading a book both at home and at the school where their parents lobbied to ban the book. (It's quite hard to access suppressed information if you lack the knowledge it exists in the first place.)

amanaplanacanaltoday at 5:05 PM

So you are suggesting that kids should just go to a different public school?

show 1 reply