logoalt Hacker News

garciasntoday at 3:44 PM4 repliesview on HN

68% of Americans supposedly support unions: https://news.gallup.com/poll/694472/labor-union-approval-rel...

Yet, ~50% of Americans voted for the party that is diametrically opposed to them; a paradox.

That said, with only about ~10% of Americans being employed in a union role, it's more like the grass is greener on the other side than an actual understanding of the pros and cons of union membership.


Replies

browsingonlytoday at 5:23 PM

> actual understanding of the pros and cons of union membership

Many of us have worked in $MEGACORPS with substantial union representation among the employees, have seen what it does and how it works in practice, and as a result want nothing to do with it. I wasn't represented due to my job classification, but now due to my firsthand exposure to unions I absolutely never will be by choice.

No way, no how, not ever.

show 1 reply
cweaganstoday at 4:53 PM

> ~50% of Americans voted for the party that is diametrically opposed to them

Less than half of the US population voted in the last election. ~50% of Americans _who voted_ voted for the party that is diametrically opposed to unions, but that group is only ~23% of _Americans_.

show 1 reply
chung8123today at 5:22 PM

This is why one issue wedge voting works. You may vote against something you want to vote for something you want more.

Whoppertimetoday at 5:55 PM

I don't think it's so obvious The International Brotherhood of Teamsters didn't officially endorse any candidate for president in 2024. This was because internal polling said that their members overwhelmingly supported Trump over Harris, while it seems like the union leadership supported Harris over Trump This is not the only Union who had a difference of opinion between leadership and membership in 2024