logoalt Hacker News

sebastiennightyesterday at 10:01 PM2 repliesview on HN

You are absolutely correct. The second suboptimal part of the prompt is this:

> Trim introductions, repetition, generic reassurance, and optional background first.

It's not possible for the model to "trim" those before they've been output, so this is akin to telling it "not think of an elephant or even take the existence of elephants into consideration while solving this problem".


Replies

SgtBastardyesterday at 10:56 PM

You may be discounting the tokens generated in the thinking trace but not included in the output to users.

brooksttoday at 12:22 AM

That would be true of non-iterative models that just emit an output from beginning to end.

No reasonable model has worked that way for years.