logoalt Hacker News

Brendinoooyesterday at 10:18 PM2 repliesview on HN

> for those of us who don't presuppose divine authorship.

There's a lot I could say in response to your comment (most notably, I think we literates underrate the ability of oral cultures to transmit information) but I just want to highlight that merely acknowledging your presupposition as a presupposition removes one of the biggest things that riles me up when I get into discussions like this. It's very much appreciated.


Replies

adgjlsfhk1yesterday at 11:14 PM

the problem with oral societies isn't that they unable to transmit information (in the Shannon sense) it's that they're really bad at transmitting information through time while separating true facts about history from fables, revisionism, bias, she intermixing with pure fiction.

tiberious726yesterday at 11:31 PM

Not presupposing something is not itself a presupposition