logoalt Hacker News

dtagamestoday at 3:21 AM2 repliesview on HN

If we can get internet from the sky, it's hard to justify digging up the earth with cables for the same thing.

I realize Space X "pollutes" space and astronomy is also important, but it's not more important than communications and information for people on earth.


Replies

afavourtoday at 4:01 AM

I disagree, maintaining a giant fleet of satellites is almost certainly more expensive in the long run than just running a lot of cable. Not that cable doesn’t need maintenance but Starlink needs to replace every satellite every five years. And they can’t recycle a thing, they just burn up.

You’re presenting a false choice. It isn’t “Starlink or no internet”, it’s “why not other internet options?”

show 1 reply
m463today at 3:59 AM

Assuming there are poles (or trenches) for electricity, cable is a modest addition.