logoalt Hacker News

Mesh LLM: distributed AI computing on iroh

90 pointsby tionisyesterday at 10:38 PM22 commentsview on HN

Comments

SwellJoeyesterday at 11:25 PM

I note the lack of performance information. I can only imagine it's much, much, slower than any other way to run a larger model (including, e.g. using system RAM and streaming some stuff from disk). Consumer networks, even 10gbit ethernet, are slow as hell compared to local RAM and even disks.

Are we talking 1 token per second for a split model? Less?

Edit: Found a number. On the models list, Qwen 235B A22B says "MoE 235B/22B, proven at 16 tok/s across 2 nodes". They don't say what the nodes are and what network connection they have, but that's a respectable speed. Not quite comfortable for interactive use, but pretty close.

show 3 replies
i386today at 12:21 AM

I’m one of the contributors to Mesh LLM and happy to answer any questions. I authored the skippy engine that allows you to split large models across nodes.

show 2 replies
darkpicnicyesterday at 11:35 PM

Does Mesh LLM encrypt the payload between nodes? Is it possible to read requests from other users?

show 2 replies
jmercourisyesterday at 10:58 PM

I thought about this too, but the throughput over a network is incredibly slow. It’s not usable for interactive use.

show 1 reply
turtleyachtyesterday at 10:49 PM

It sounds like iroh enables distributed compute without having to finangle custom hardware.

darkpicnicyesterday at 11:19 PM

cocompute.ai is already doing this really well.

show 2 replies
_superposition_today at 12:36 AM

I just wish I had the hardware to try it out!

jing09928today at 1:34 AM

[dead]

nttylockyesterday at 11:01 PM

[flagged]

tlongwell-blocktoday at 12:24 AM

[dead]