logoalt Hacker News

Fable extended until 19 July

64 pointsby protoman3000today at 5:14 PM29 commentsview on HN

Comments

AM1010101today at 9:01 PM

PLEASE MAKE UP YOUR MIND.

I have claude, codex, cursor and kiro, all most basic teir and swap around. I like anthropic the best. I would have upgraded to Claude Max 20x by now (and dropped the others) if you would just incldue an amount of fable in the subscription. I would have done it on the first of this month if I'd know fable would be included until the 19th. However I'm not sure I want to at all as I feel you will just rug pull me or string me along in another way and constantly be threatening to change things. I have other stuff to think about, the last thing I want is my tool provider constantly changing their mind on things, making me waste mental energy on -p or fable access.

I don't really want to but it would be so much easier to just go with codex right now...

thepaschtoday at 5:22 PM

Can Anthropic please just decide on what their plan is with Fable instead of kicking the can down the road last-second every time and consequently destroying all notions of being able to plan out one's weekly usage expenditure?

show 3 replies
throwa356262today at 6:03 PM

Question to HN:

How many of you actually need the SOTA level intelligence of Sol and Fable? What kind of tasks do you use it for, and what did you do 6 months ago when SOTA models were as intelligent as today's B team?

The other day I tried a 31B model from a Canadian company and felt this is good enough for 80-90% of my tasks.

(For the cuorious: North Mini Code. Free on OpenCode/Zen right now. No affiliation :) )

show 5 replies
sscaryterrytoday at 8:45 PM

Anthropic keeps on burning people the same way. Destroy the little (if any) trust left... The competitors will eat you alive.

mil22today at 5:21 PM

Finally, I can sleep... I'd been working non-stop all weekend to use Fable before it disappeared tomorrow. Now, please, a reset. ;)

show 1 reply
dpc10today at 6:42 PM

For whatever reason I've preferred, at least so far, Fable to 5.6. I've spent the time since Fable's return being very cautious about when and how I use it, whereas with 5.6 (especially given OpenAI's generous limit resets) I'm pretty liberal about using it for lots of things that in the long run I could do with a less capable model.

Psychologically, I think that approach has made me value the delicate, ephemeral creature that is Fable more than I otherwise might. I don't know if that was Anthropic's plan, but if it was it worked on me at least.

But there's a limit to how many times they can play this card. Eventually either Fable has to blow me away so much that it justifies the API spend (it hasn't yet), or I have to decide that I can't rely on it, and I develop an approach that leans on it less heavily.

I don't know when we hit the tipping point from scarcity increasing perceived value to uncertainty reducing real value, but it can't be that far away.

show 1 reply
giorgioztoday at 6:25 PM

I've been trying Fable 5 and GPT 5.6 Sol last few days. My impression is that Sol consumes a lot less tokens that Fable 5 being comparable. Gpt 5.6 Sol can be run sustainably on one 20x plan. Fable 5 requires 2-3 20x plans to be run sustainably. I think the best move move for Anthropic would be to release an Opus 5 that is actually as cheap as Sol and comparably good. They have released a Fable 5 and Sonnet 5 so that seems like a possible move but I'm not sure whether the Opus 5 they got is already at Sol level. Claude Code terminal is still better than Codex CLI though as an harness. Claude code Ultramode + workflow is unmatched by Codex harness yet in my experience.

msp26today at 6:18 PM

Deeply unserious company, flip flopping on policy every week with ludicrous, sometimes invisible, guard rails on their top model. Imagine trying to make business decisions about AI use with this.

I love Fable for many things including coding but I cannot justify basing any internal AI tools or LLM powered products on top of Anthropic's offerings.

trashfacetoday at 8:25 PM

Not using it, because they keep saying they are going either take it away or charge a lot more for it. They seriously screwed up the messaging on this thing.

vmt-mantoday at 6:46 PM

So, do you want me to trust technology you will shut down for some reason in random time? No, thanks :)

volf_today at 5:34 PM

Keep using Fable. Don't think about using GPT 5.6 Sol

Avicebrontoday at 5:17 PM

Sweet! Safeguards seem a bit over-tuned this morning, it was working on Lenia all night and now it won't touch it.

dude250711today at 7:04 PM

Anthropic land: praying for Fable, dreaming of Mythos.

Open AI land: simply using 5.6 Sol Max.

firemelttoday at 6:52 PM

idk dude but at my use case fable is not even better than opus 4.8 on xhigh

so gone or not I dont think I miss a shit

zarzavattoday at 5:20 PM

Nobody could have predicted this.

show 1 reply
bdelmastoday at 7:45 PM

I still have no idea if they really want to make Fable usable in a plan in the future or not. They said it's their goal but here they still double down that it will be out of plans, period.