logoalt Hacker News

heyheyheytoday at 5:35 PM1 replyview on HN

Comparing a podcast to a book is like comparing a 30-minute TV episode to a 3 hour Scorsese movie. Similar mediums with completely different goals.


Replies

dredmorbiustoday at 7:14 PM

It really depends on the podcast as well.

There are podcasts which are just free-association rambling (or worse), others which are very closely scripted and edited.

I very much prefer the latter, and the best of those approach books in structure and/or value, if they don't directly produce books themselves (e.g., Peter Adamson's History of Philosophy, which is both a podcast and a book series).