logoalt Hacker News

sam1ryesterday at 9:25 PM5 repliesview on HN

[flagged]


Replies

JoshTriplettyesterday at 9:46 PM

> I really feel like "grab" is quite condescending

By all means, let's use a more appropriate term, like "abuse" or "misappropriate". It's not sufficiently condescending for a company that's trying to train AI on people's private health data.

show 1 reply
BigTTYGothGFyesterday at 9:54 PM

> condescending

How can you be "condescending" to a company?

show 1 reply
Barbingyesterday at 9:54 PM

Samsung can mitigate the harm and frustration by providing users options. Would you prefer this pathway of their way or the highway?

ben_wyesterday at 10:00 PM

> I really feel like "grab" is quite condescending to a company (Samsung) that provides services at scale (upon/after consent) to help you.. "be better" (simplified..), with direct customization and tailoring.

The headline as described sounds to me like they're violating GDPR by tying to force "consent" for a not-strictly-necessary-for-functionality use of health data. The European Data Protection Board has repeatedly stated that consent is (generally) not considered to be "freely given" if there is a significant detriment for refusing it or if the user has no genuine choice.

Note however that caveat: as described. There may be some more details which make this not unlawful. Also, actually deleting your data if you don't consent is the kind of thing GDPR requires.

customguyyesterday at 9:29 PM

"snatch with their spider leg like fingers that are dripping with digestive fluid"