logoalt Hacker News

philistinetoday at 2:13 AM3 repliesview on HN

Those two resistors cost money. It's not incompetence. It's a deliberate choice.


Replies

Tharretoday at 2:58 AM

You're saving a fraction of a cent per device, while banking on customers not sending it back as defective because it didn't charge when they tried it with a random cable.

If it is a deliberate choice, it's a really, really dumb one.

show 2 replies
klempnertoday at 3:35 AM

One of my theories is that there is a deliberate choice happening by people who don't realize it is as simple as a couple of resistors and think they need some fancy PD negotiation chip.

Even over on r/usbchardware it is super common for people to conflate "PD" with this missing resistor issue. Part of the confusion is that the devices that people want to charge with are very likely to be PD power supplies.

m463today at 4:49 AM

I've read countless stories of designs sent out getting backroom-cost-reduced by removing the most ridiculously cheap parts.