logoalt Hacker News

Terr_yesterday at 7:05 PM1 replyview on HN

> socialist than capitalist [...] federal tax rate

My dude, you're acting like Federal government is the only government that matters. It's a common mistake, but in this context it's fatal to your argument.

It's fatal because federal spending is the least relevant kind, since so much of it (and so much of its growth) is for the military, and military spending indicates very little about whether a country is socialist or capitalist on the inside.

In contrast, state/local taxes and programs are--even today--still a majority of the spending that actually tells us anything useful for a socialist/capitalist spectrum, the stuff that involves schools, libraries, policing, homelessness, property rights, etc.


Replies

DoesntMatter22yesterday at 9:45 PM

"since so much of it (and so much of its growth) is for the military"

So clearly you are pretty uninformed as the military spending is only 13% of the federal budget. Social Security (AKA a socialist program, IDK if anyone can deny that) is 22%, Medicare (another socialist program is 14.2%). Interest on our prior spending (a lot of it from SS and Medicare, etc, some military too. is 14%

So, if you add social programs you has (SS = 22.5%, Medicare = 14.2%, not counting education) that is 36% of the budget or nearly 3x miltitary spending.

A capitalist economy would NOT have those things are as they are not free market at all, they are the government forcing your to pay into them.

show 1 reply