Yes I do agree. It's not that Tokio has taken over just due to community momentum. There's a certain subtle lock-in that happens due to how the Rust type system and dependency system work together. It's a hard problem to address.

Regarding mixed IO/compute and preemptive scheduling, well that's what threads are. They are not as lightweight, but they are there and they are quite ergonomic to use in Rust.

I could even imagine an async executor that simply starts a thread per task, so that you can keep the nice syntax, but that's obviously not ideal from a performance standpoint. Tokio already dispatches tasks to a thread pool, it is not completely cooperative, it's the sensible way to do this. And there's always tokio::spawn_blocking too.

PS: Actually, it is underrated how well designed classic threading is in Rust. It was just going out of vogue when they did it, but they addressed so much of the complexity that was around for years in Java, C++ and the like. They did actually mostly achieve the holy grail of fearless concurrency and with a more ergonomic design.