logoalt Hacker News

dominotwtoday at 12:31 PM2 repliesview on HN

> I can’t help but wonder whether constant use of “agent” harnesses will lead to an atrophy of the software engineering (or really any field) muscles.

For sure. You cannot have "only higher level thoughts" without doing lower level work.

Ironically llm themselves prove that because you cannot remove facts like 'paris is capital of france' from llm and have it just retain 'high level thoughts' like 'countries have capitals that you can look up'


Replies

skinfaxitoday at 12:50 PM

> For sure. You cannot have "only higher level thoughts" without doing lower level work

What do you mean? I think people routinely think about things at a very high level with almost no understanding of the lower levels. How many people use a computer each day and reason about them at a very high level while knowing nothing of capacitors, logic gates, or programming languages?

show 2 replies
themgttoday at 12:52 PM

For sure. You cannot have "only higher level thoughts" without doing lower level work.

Spend 3 days a week writing Ruby on Rails and 2 days hand rolling x86 assembly. Every web dev I know has been doing this since long before LLMs. Ensures they can keep having high level Rails thoughts.

show 1 reply