logoalt Hacker News

philipallstaryesterday at 12:41 PM3 repliesview on HN

> In March, the National Audit Office released a report noting that the Scunthorpe steelworks was costing the government about £1.3m a day.

No, BBC, the government doesn't have money. It costs the net taxpayer that much a day.


Replies

KaiserProyesterday at 12:56 PM

When I buy something, it doesn't cost my employer, it costs me.

the pedantry here isn't helpful, as its "not other peoples money" is a monetary system that the government lets us use.

I understand that frustration about frivolous spending. It would be better if the argument was on how we evolve and change the steel market here in the UK so its self funding.

BUT!

the whole discourse about "government shouldn't choose winners" is a bit flawed, because we have left it to business to invest in infra, and mostly they've just outsourced to someone else (who's government actually planned with an industrial strategy)

p_lyesterday at 12:58 PM

GBP is a fiat currency issued by government through government spending and destroyed by government through taxation, it does not cost the taxpayer it's at worst a bad allocation of resources or incentivization of resource allocation.

iberatoryesterday at 2:54 PM

The government has its own money. For example from national owned companies like airlines, mines, factories etc

Richest countries have a lot of government owned companies. USA is just an anomaly because of Chicago school of economy.

This is a common myth spreaded by free market freaks.