alt Hacker NewsThe problems are simply too great if an LLM detector has any false positives at all. Imagine how soul-crushing writing an entire dissertation by hand and having it rejected because some “good enough” LLM detector decides you write too much like an AI.
Replies
dmurvihill • today at 6:40 PM
It depends on the application. Dissertation? Hell naw. Blog post? Absolutely, run it through that thing.
➕ show 1 reply
As I recall, a few years ago (in the era of first generation LLMs), a professor in Texas used an anti-plagiarism tool that flagged more than one-third of the class using AI in an exam, and used that finding to give them a failing grade.
If memory serves, one student objected strenously and ran the professor's own work (published 10 years earlier) into the same tool and it flagged that work as AI-generated.
EDIT: HN item from June 2023 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36215823