logoalt Hacker News

BeetleByesterday at 11:01 PM4 repliesview on HN

It's not an indictment of modern software. It's an indictment of using SW where not needed.

Don't put discrete, isolated HW functions behind a SW powered screen. It's that simple.


Replies

lmzyesterday at 11:29 PM

It's Android Auto and Apple Carplay. Not sure how that's an "isolated HW function". That would be an issue if they put the turn signals or AC controls on the screen only.

strawhatguyyesterday at 11:28 PM

Pretty much this. The less software on the car, the fewer problems.

It's practically impossible to test every permutation of code against every system. Maybe AI can help, but practically it'll just mean the software gets more complicated, with more features. And to top it all off, more and more features get regulated, so they have to be there. The rear-view camera requirement in particular, since you need a screen to see the output. And if you have a screen... well it's an already paid cost, so, might as well display other things too.

We should kill the reg.

show 1 reply
taneqyesterday at 11:39 PM

It’s an indictment of business attitudes towards customers. It’s not the software’s fault, the software is doing what it was supposed to. The fault lies with the organisation that decided that’s what it should do.

tonymetyesterday at 11:36 PM

wouldn't that be impossible in this case? since android auto needs to draw to the screen, control infotainment, etc. even a dedicated USB + rocker switch for android auto would still need a software path to do those things