logoalt Hacker News

red369yesterday at 6:05 AM9 repliesview on HN

I once expected an aftermarket industry to pop-up to hybridize old cars. Old rear-wheel drive manual cars sound easiest.

Generator attached to the flywheel instead of the starter motor, and then find some way to squeeze a drive motor by the rear diff (probably more complicated, but surely not impossible). I thought something might pop up once companies like Bosch started making generic e-axles for manufacturers to use.

With a small Li-ion battery (and all the usual inverters, etc.), it could work like a manually operated version of the dual-motor Honda hybrid system. Put it into neutral, and whatever energy is in the battery could drive the motor on the rear axle. The engine could automatically kick-in and drive the generator if there's not enough in the battery.

It would never be as economical as a purpose-built hybrid, but old manual cars are often reasonably economical on the open road, and terrible in city traffic. Targeting only the urban fuel consumption would go a long way towards keeping them useable, with the added bonus of making manual shifting optional in stop-go traffic. Small motors would be enough for city speeds, and with a small battery, it sounds cheap to me at least.

I doubt it could ever be a simple kit, but I thought people would have a go.


Replies

studogyesterday at 7:01 AM

People probably are having a go. Here's one for pickups: https://edisonmotors.ca/trucks/pickup-conversion/

dajtyesterday at 11:40 PM

We had a guy give a talk at our local nerd meet-up about doing this to an old landrover with the hopes of commercialising it. Did a good job, but it was only for someone with money to burn.

Looks like he did commercialise it: https://www.jauntmotors.com/series

I recognise some of the photos from back then.

Scoundrelleryesterday at 4:40 PM

> Generator attached to the flywheel instead of the starter motor, and then find some way to squeeze a drive motor by the rear diff (probably more complicated, but surely not impossible).

Some vehicles have this as a “battery starter generator” where the “hybrid” functionality is entirely on the accessory belt.

https://www.bosch.com/stories/48v-hybrid-battery/

https://hackaday.com/2025/01/24/bosch-starter-motor-freed-fr...

rzerowanyesterday at 12:03 PM

Wouldnt the weight of the old chassis be a impedement to mods , older models tended to be more robustly buildt. Or what cut-off date for mods would be appropriate (last 10 years?) as beyond a certain cutoff would not be cost effective and most likely would be a hobby project done for the love of it.

Scoundrelleryesterday at 4:35 PM

I was thinking of a “feature” on manuals that ran electrical and accessory-belt stuff full blast during engine braking.

The best time to run your a/c or turn the seat warmers: when you’re trying to expel energy.

Would give you some extra braking without heating up the engine and take a small load off your brakes.

That or turn any vehicle into a mild plug-in hybrid for all electrical loads and flywheel the alternator until that time. Gasoline-powered generators are not very efficient.

Might get a few percent extra efficiency without having to touch anything mechanical.

humanpotatoyesterday at 5:04 PM

Automotive engineer here. One consideration for the diff motor is that it would REALLY sag the diff. I think the only way to go would be a front and rear generator/motor combo in one housing to replace the transmission, powering the rear end with a driveshaft. A direct drive clutch between the front and rear motor/generator would economize driving and assure high power at high speeds.

show 1 reply
kfseyesterday at 9:46 AM

My guess:

1) New cars are too cheap to make at scale.

2) Old cars are quite unsafe to drive, comparatively (airbags, backup cameras, lane departure alerts, blind angle alerts, etc)

show 4 replies
yobboyesterday at 6:35 AM

Stuff like this exists for bicycles. For mopeds and motorcycles there are electrification kits.

It should be possible to just replace the flywheel altogether with a generator/motor that both brakes and powers during each cycle, cancelling vibrations. Then more generation during deceleration, and more power during acceleration.

mattgriceyesterday at 3:47 PM

In the US RWD manual cars have been exclusively sport/GT for decades. They aren't cheap and a hybrid swap and/or daily driving miles would destroy their value.