> - Sensible permission system - when the agent runs git diff && rm -rf /, what do you think will happen in your current coding agent? It will treat it as git *. Maki uses tree-sitter to parse the bash command and figure out the permissions requested are git * and rm *. Disable using --yolo.
This sounds identical to what OpenCode does (&, contrary to their own marketing, does not seem sensible at all).
The fact that this mechanism is so primitive across all agentic clis is frankly a serious indictment of the competence & experience behind LLM-focused development teams.
This is a security issue that has in the past been solved via explicit file-path-based allowlisting, & more recently - due to file-path matching being deemed insufficiently secure - apps have been switching to cryptographically signed binary matching as a more modern alternative to the less secure path matching. In that context, the fact these recently-written "modern" agentic clis are using a method that's more basic & even less secure than the "old insecure" method most apps use is pretty shocking.
alt Hacker News
> - Sensible permission system - when the agent runs git diff && rm -rf /, what do you think will happen in your current coding agent? It will treat it as git *. Maki uses tree-sitter to parse the bash command and figure out the permissions requested are git * and rm *. Disable using --yolo.
This sounds identical to what OpenCode does (&, contrary to their own marketing, does not seem sensible at all).
The fact that this mechanism is so primitive across all agentic clis is frankly a serious indictment of the competence & experience behind LLM-focused development teams.
This is a security issue that has in the past been solved via explicit file-path-based allowlisting, & more recently - due to file-path matching being deemed insufficiently secure - apps have been switching to cryptographically signed binary matching as a more modern alternative to the less secure path matching. In that context, the fact these recently-written "modern" agentic clis are using a method that's more basic & even less secure than the "old insecure" method most apps use is pretty shocking.