logoalt Hacker News

ranger_dangeryesterday at 8:13 PM3 repliesview on HN

For comparison, the best performing GPUs today can do FP32 at > 100 TFLOP/s


Replies

pixelpoetyesterday at 8:34 PM

Zen3 isn't the best performing CPU today, though of course it'll never approach GPU level (which is pretty much ASIC level for matrix muls with special units). CPUs are getting dedicated "AI accelerators" too so it'd be interesting to compare per watt. The real limit is almost certainly memory bandwidth, not flops.

It would also be very interesting to see someone like Fabien Giesen / ryg do a maxed out AVX512 version for Zen5. His code's so fast it makes Intel 13900k's self destruct.

show 1 reply
adrian_byesterday at 8:42 PM

The throughput quoted here is for a single core, and it is not reported any attempt to measure how well this scales to all cores.

A modern Zen 5 should reach a throughput more than twice this value per core, with a total over 3 TFLOP/s for the complete CPU.

That 100 TFLOP/s for FP32 is for a GPU that might cost from 30 to 100 times more than a desktop CPU, so it is not certain that its performance per dollar is any better than for the desktop CPU.

This is very different from 7 to 10 years ago, when GPUs had a far higher performance per dollar than any CPUs. Since then, the performance per dollar of the desktop CPUs has increased, mainly because their prices have not increased much, while the performance per dollar of the GPUs has decreased, mainly because of a great increase in their prices, especially for the "datacenter" GPUs, which now may be more than 10 times more expensive than they were 7 years ago.

zamadatixyesterday at 9:11 PM

Certainly not in a single core (however the given GPU wishes to define it)? This comparison would seem more apt to the largest multi-core CPU results.