logoalt Hacker News

hangonhnyesterday at 9:28 PM1 replyview on HN

"I have used more than a few systems with ECC UDIMMs and I recommend avoiding them if convenient as ECC UDIMMs are expensive on the second hand market while ECC RDIMMs can get very cheap."

Boy did I learn that the hard way. I found an ASRock server motherboard that fit my needs for a NAS perfectly. I just assumed all ECC memory were registered so I didn't even bother to check. I had already put everything together minus the memory. I had actually purchased the memory and had to return them because they were RDIMMs and get the ECC UDIMMs for quite a bit more. Luckily this was just before the AI induced price spike.


Replies

etbeyesterday at 11:13 PM

A very large portion of people who go from working on consumer grade systems to getting enterprise grade stuff for their home lab make a mistake like that, I did some similar things, my biggest mistake was spending $300 on non-refundable ECC RDIMMs without realising that my server (the cheapest Dell Txxx server) took ECC UDIMMs.

I hope that my blog posts on these topics will save some people some money.