logoalt Hacker News

fhdkweigyesterday at 10:14 PM5 repliesview on HN

Honest question. Does asking "make no mistakes" actually change the output? Does it make mistakes if you don't bother to ask for no mistakes? Is it just to make the human feel more secure?


Replies

minimaxiryesterday at 10:19 PM

It's a meme. Telling it to "make no mistakes" doesn't do anything because LLMs don't have an inherent concept of a mistake and they are already RLHFed to code correctly.

However, if you tell it to not do particular behaviors explicitly—some of which would be considered mistakes—it will not do said behaviors and with enough checks and balances, you'll get output without "mistakes".

One example of this from the OpenAI Unit Distance prompt: https://cdn.openai.com/pdf/04d1d1e4-bc75-476a-97cf-49055cd98...

> Do not return merely because current approaches fail or agents report theorem-strength gaps. Continue launching new rounds, reopening blocked approaches only when there is a genuinely new mechanism, and searching for fresh formulations. Return only when a complete affirmative proof has been found and survives adversarial audit.

> Do not return a reduction, partial result, isolated missing lemma, “best effort” summary, or explanation of why the problem is difficult.

show 2 replies
saganusyesterday at 10:21 PM

It's just a meme at this point.

jewelyesterday at 10:20 PM

I believe it's a reference to a joke meme that goes something like "Write Windows 12 from scratch. Make no mistakes." At least that's the first context I heard it in.

show 1 reply
hyperhelloyesterday at 10:16 PM

It will make mistakes if you tell it to, so I assume it will make no mistakes if you tell it not to.

show 1 reply
greenavocadoyesterday at 10:52 PM

> Does asking "make no mistakes" actually change the output?

Why Teams Add "Make No Mistakes" to AI Prompts (And Why It Never Works)

https://jakemcmahon.github.io/medium-articles/make-no-mistak...