logoalt Hacker News

jrfloyesterday at 11:54 PM2 repliesview on HN

Doesn't disqualify them, but it may call into question their results seeing as they have a potential conflict of interest.


Replies

mdp2021today at 6:55 AM

> a potential conflict of interest

That seems to be actually a simple direct interest.

And, there is the "my product is good" confirmation to the outside incentive, there is the (only potentially) conflicting truth incentive, but there are also internal mission studies needs - so that you do not research into the benchmarks just to show people that "your product is good".

> call into question their results

That's always valid, so the question becomes "how much", and at that point the important side is difficult to evaluate - especially because in a frequentistic, Bayesian context the quantities were just potential anyway ("This will increase the chances - yes, of course just the chances - of E by some amount").