logoalt Hacker News

sheeshkebablast Thursday at 4:12 PM5 repliesview on HN

Someone going to public library, copying every book out of it and then selling them as their own are thieves.


Replies

RiverCrochetlast Thursday at 5:16 PM

Not technically theft unless the public library no longer has the books. Selling something and saying you created it when you didn't is a different five-letter word: fraud.

Putting prompts in an LLM and saying you "created" the image or text thereof is fraud.

sscaryterrylast Thursday at 4:15 PM

I don't believe anything is being sold here :)

show 2 replies
__MatrixMan__last Thursday at 5:18 PM

No, they've merely infringed copyright. Theft is a well understood concept and it does not pertain to information.

lcnPylGDnU4H9OFlast Thursday at 4:43 PM

Okay, but that's not what happened as far as I'm aware. Who did they sell their copies of the books to?