logoalt Hacker News

stusmalllast Thursday at 5:48 PM4 repliesview on HN

I can't wrap my head around the idea that distillation is IP theft but mass training on books, music and art without consent is fair use. The two stances are incompatible. If it is transformative use of a book, it is transformative use of AI output.


Replies

BoxOfRainlast Thursday at 6:14 PM

Yeah people in the US who want protectionism for US models on grounds of IP rights are appalling hypocrites. What’s good for the goose is good for the gander!

munk-alast Thursday at 6:15 PM

I really hope that when a sane administration returns to power in the US we'll actually get a reckoning over how irrational it was to not restrict training data.

slashdavelast Thursday at 10:52 PM

No, it is stealing the R&D of another company.

show 1 reply
henryfjordanlast Thursday at 7:30 PM

Is it? Turning a book into an AI model is lot more transformative than turning an AI Model into another AI Model.