logoalt Hacker News

williamdclttoday at 12:49 PM1 replyview on HN

Well so far we've been using humans to clean up the code that humans ruined in the first place, it's hardly a logical fallacy


Replies

giancarlostorotoday at 4:12 PM

The pearl clutching about AI is insane to me, as if code quality was perfect before 2022. We have been seeing a decline in software quality for a long time coming now. A lot of AI hatred is not even based on seeing something genuinely bad, its just prejudice for the sake of prejudice. If I could view into two parallel worlds, one where I vibe code something, release it and tell people it's vibe coded, and another where I do the same but tell no one, codebases are both the same and I still reviewed the code, had the model fix issues with code quality and bugs, and genuinely invested hours of my time to raise up, in the universe where I don't mention AI, people will likely sing praises, in the universe where I do mention AI, people will not even review or view a single line of code, they will close the tab, hop back on HN and complain that it's AI slop, without any reasonable reason.

Blind AI hatred is just insane to me and it goes against the spirit of HN, we're not supposed to just go "ITS BAD CODE" here, we are supposed to have actual engaging conversations. Too much of HN devolves into "ITS SLOP" instead of "Hey, I know you're leaning on the AI a bit, but here's what's wrong with the code: ...." which would be more constructive and fall better in line with what I've expected from HN and seen for years, until recently.

AI fatigue and AI prejudice should not be confused for one another, sure you can have both, but most people who hate AI blindly just have AI prejudice at this point.

show 1 reply