logoalt Hacker News

Hnrobert42today at 2:33 AM3 repliesview on HN

Is the high success rate because they are good at winning or good at picking winning cases? Does that 90% include plea bargains?


Replies

RRWagnertoday at 4:37 AM

I've been on jury duty several times and in each time the entire jury pool was dismissed an hour or so into the morning, with "all cases have been settled". As I was leaving, the official said, "see how efficient we are now?". I replied, "The guillotine is efficient, but it's not justice." Look into Aaron Swartz. The % of cases that go to trial is very small, in no small part because plea bargaining is no bargain at all. "Plead guilty and we'll do the minimum (whether you're actually guilty or not), or go to trial and we will seek the maximum sentence, which could be 30 years in prison. What's your answer?"

Exoristostoday at 2:38 AM

You're begging OP's question.

show 2 replies